Breast Augmentation: Saline or Silicone?

liposuction south jerseyThe FDA approved silicone implants for use in cosmetic augmentation in 2006.  This has added a great option for many patients but also added some confusion as to which type of implant is best for a particular patient.  The most important difference between silicone gel and saline filled implants is the issue of rupture.  All breast implants, being artificial devices, have to behave in a friendly biological fashion to integrate appropriately in living tissue.  They also must have properties that make them desirable for their intended use.  Softness, pliability, and shape are important properties but these characteristics play a role in the longevity of the device.  Currently, the major manufacturers of breast implants in this country (Mentor and Allergan) list an anticipated longevity of ten years for their implants.  However, there is no guarantee that any implant will last for any specified period of time.  Although we discuss the rupture rate in terms of a percent each year, it stands to reason that the rupture rate for a breast implant is 100% – eventually.  Rupture is really where the 2 types of implants part ways in a practical sense.  The saline implant, filled with salt water, will simply deflate over a period of days following rupture.  The loss of volume is immediate and usually quite noticeable to the patient.  No special test is necessary to confirm what is obvious. The filler, salt water in this case, is simply absorbed by the body and excreted by the kidneys in the usual fashion.

Silicone gel filled implant rupture is another matter.  The filler in this case, a cohesive silicone gel, is not absorbed by the body.  Therefore, the volume of the breast changes little following rupture.  Although there is a chance of a slight change in the shape and/or feel of the implant following rupture, it is well known that this change is subtle, and will likely be missed by both the patient and her surgeon.  The FDA required labeling consistent with this problem, recommending MRI screening for silicone breast implants beginning at three years post implantation followed by every other year thereafter.  Unfortunately, the MRI is not without its own problems.  There is a significant false positive rate on screening (it sees a rupture when there isn’t).  It is also expensive, not being covered by health insurance when the implants were placed for cosmetic purposes.  I encourage all of my patients with silicone-gel filled implants to carefully consider the FDA recommendations for MRI screening.  As more information becomes available for these devices, modification of the current recommendation should follow.

So, why would a woman choose one implant over another?

While it is true that both saline filled and silicone-gel filled breast implants are effective in providing larger, more shapely breasts, some women benefit from the better texture and more natural feel of the silicone-gel filled breast implant. For example, smaller breasted women typically benefit most from the silicone-gel filled implant as the presence of any implant is more difficult to conceal. There is less fat and breast tissue to cover the implant, and so problems such as wrinkling can be more severe. In addition, women who have had children can experience involution of the breast gland, leaving a softer, thinner breast which may feel strange over a the typically firmer saline implant.

So how does a patient choose?

Except in the specific circumstances noted above, it is very hard to tell the difference simply by looking.  They are both good at making breasts round and full.  Most of the improvement in result is largely due to texture and feel.  This makes it a personal choice by the patient based on her own goals.  As proof to myself, I have been present at international meetings of plastic surgeons where photographs of patients with breast implants are shown on the screen.  The surgeon audience members are then asked to vote, “Saline or Silicone?”  We plastic surgeons cannot guess any better than chance!  Of course photographs are not the same as the real thing, but it certainly makes a point.  The bottom line is that the decision rests with the patient.  My job is to relate the facts and make recommendations based on sound surgical practice

Dr Franckle

Meet Dr. William Franckle Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

We know that you have many options when choosing a plastic surgeon. Dr. Franckle and his staff are dedicated to providing you with a caring and professional surgical experience. Time and time again our patients credit Dr. Franckle’s expertise and the kindness of our staff as the reason for choosing our practice. Dr. Franckle is board certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (ASPS), the only board recognized by the American Board of Medical Specialties to certify surgeons in the practice of plastic surgery. Attention to detail, meticulous skill, and an artistic eye make Dr. Franckle an expert in such procedures as rhinoplasty (nose job), breast augmentation (breast implants), abdominoplasty (tummy tuck), facelift, and non-surgical treatments (Botox and injectable fillers).

Dr. William Franckle Testimonials

ZO Skin Health is here! ⁠

The growth in popularity of less invasive treatments, such as Botox and injectable fillers, has led to the development of more scientific, more effective skincare. ⁠

The growth in popularity of anti-aging treatments among our patients has lead us to add another option to our list of cosmetic treatments. ⁠

ZO Skin Health, the latest innovation of Dr. Zein Obagi, creator of OBAGI products is now available at our office!⁠


#skinnj #njskin #njcosmestics #cosmeticsurgeon #fillers #botox #njskinhealth #zoskinhealth #antiaging

Did you know you can check our our reviews right on our website? See what they're saying and book your consult today! >> #LINKINBIO⁠⁠

#njplasticsurgeon #njcosmetics #njplasticsurgery #njmommymakeover #njmakeober #njlife #njsurgeonreviews

Happy Independence Day!⁠

#4thofjuly #holidayweekend #plasticsurgeonnj #njplastcsurgery #vorheesnj #cherryhillnj #njcosmetics

Fillers FAQ: How Is the Recovery Process?⁠

Here we go! >>⁠

As a non-invasive procedure, Dr. Franckle will administer the smooth gel treatment via an injection.⁠

Mild bruising, redness, itching, and swelling are normal reactions at the injection site and should subside in 2-4 weeks or less. ⁠

Once the swelling reduces, patients typically start to notice results 2-3 weeks after treatment. ⁠

Find out more on our website vis #LINKINBIO⁠

#njfillers #Juvederm #njlipfillers #njcosmetics #nonsurgical #njmedspa #vorheesnj⁠


REMINDER: We’re Hiring! 🌟⁠

We are looking for our next All-Star Front Desk Coordinator – This is a full time position⁠

Email your resume to⁠

#njjobs #vorheesnj #cherryhillnj #njhiring #hiringvorhees #vorheesnj #jerseyjobs #frontdeskcoordinator #applynow

" From consultation to surgery and a year worth of follow ups, Dr.Franckle has been amazing. ⁠

He truly listens to his patients and adds his expertise to provide amazing results. I've wanted to have a breast augmentation completed for many years. I've even spoke with other surgeons.⁠

As soon as I had the consultation with Dr. Franckle, I booked the procedure. ⁠

He made me feel at ease, answered every question I had and genuinely cared for my input and how I felt. ⁠

His office staff is also wonderful and very attentive. I'm very satisfied with my results and would highly recommend." - Breast Aug (Jan 2021)⁠

#surgeonreview #njplasticsurgeon #njsurgeon #njbreastaug #njpatientreview #plasticsurgeonreview

Here for you 🖤⁠

#breastlift #mommymakeover #njplasticsurgeon #njmoms #cherryhillnj #njlipo #njtummytuck #plasticsurgeonreview

We’re Hiring! 🌟⁠

We are looking for our next All-Star Front Desk Coordinator – This is a full time position⁠

Email your resume to⁠

#njjobs #vorheesnj #cherryhillnj #njhiring #hiringvorhees #vorheesnj #jerseyjobs #frontdeskcoordinator #applynow

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.

William Franckle, MD., FACS

| | 856.772.6500
Call Now Button